angel

Oil on canvas painting of Archangel Michael defeating Satan by Guido Reni, c.1636. A fair-haired angel wearing an armored breastplate and holding a sword in one hand and a chain in the other places its foot on the head of a prone Satan.

Oil on canvas painting of Archangel Michael defeating Satan by Guido Reni, c.1636. A fair-haired angel wearing an armored breastplate and holding a sword in one hand and a chain in the other places its foot on the head of a prone Satan.

14 November 2022

Being a Christian religious term, it is no surprise that angel traces back to Old English. The Old English word comes from the Greek ἄγγελος (angelos), literally messenger, via the Latin angelus, reinforced in Middle English by the Anglo-Norman aungel. The Old English engel appears some 2,250 times in the extant corpus, one such occurrence coming from Ælfric of Eynsham’s sermon for Christmas, written in the late tenth century:

Ðreo þing synd on middanearde, an is hwilwendlic, þe hæfð ægðer ge ordfrumman ge ende, þæt synd nytenu and ealle sawullease þing þe ongunnan þa þa hi god gesceop and æft geændiað and to nahte gewurðaþ. Oðer þing is ece swa þæt hit hæfð ordfruman and næfð nenne ende; þæt synd ænglas and manna saula, þe ongunnen ða þa hi god gesceop, ac hi ne geendiað næfre. Dridde þing is ece swa þæt hit næfð naðor ne ordfruman ne ende, þæt is se ana ælmihtiga god on þrynesse and on annysse æfre wuniende unasmeagendlic and unasæcgendlic.

(There are three things on this earth: one is transitory, that has both a beginning and an end; such are beasts and all soulless things which began when God created them and afterward end and turn to nothing. The second thing is eternal, so that it has a beginning and does not have an end; such are the angels and the souls of humans, which began when God created them, but they never end. The third thing is eternal, so that it has neither a beginning nor an end; such is the one almighty God in trinity and unity, who continues forever inconceivable and indescribable.)

The figurative sense of angel meaning a virtuous person is in place by the fifteenth century. It appears in William Caxton’s translation from the French of Raoul Le Fevre’s History of Jason, in the passage where Medea kills her son Jason, who is named after his father:

“Ha. a Iason my dere sone thy figure & semblaunt. and thy faders entresemble & ben lik. Thou art moche fayr if thou mightiest come to thaage of a man / certes thou sholdest ensiewe and folowe the maners of thy fader the most double & leest trew knight of the worlde. hit is moche better that thou deye an angel in thy yongth / thenne a deuill in thy olde aage” / and wythoute more speking or other bewaillyng she drew out a sharp knyf in the presence of the norices that wyste not what to saye. and smote him with the knif vnto the herte. And after departed at that oure that men might not see her.

(“Ah, Jason my dear son, your figure and countenance resembles and is like your father’s. You would be very handsome if you would come to the age of a man; it is certain that you would ensue and follow the manners of your father, the most double and least true knight in the world. It is much better that you die an angel in your youth than a devil in your old age,” and without any more speaking or bewailing, she drew out a sharp knife in the presence of the nurses who did not know what to say and smote him with the knife into the heart. And afterward, she departed at that hour so that men might not see her.)

In traditional Christian theology, angels are immortal beings that predate the creation of the world and of humanity. The idea that humans, at least those with God’s grace, become angels when they die is a much more recent one, dating to the late eighteenth century. Here is an example from Elizabeth Helme’s 1787 novel Louisa:

I composed my features as well as possible, that they might not be an index of the contending passions that dwelt within, and obeyed my summons to the drawing room, where I was repossessed, like Mary, in favour of the stranger, who was a likely man, seemingly about the age of thirty-eight. He rose at my entrance—“Ah! Madam, said he, it is indeed the daughter of my friend, the living image of her angel mother;” and he embraced me with a fatherly affection.

And the sense of angel meaning a financial backer of some venture, got its start in theater circles in the latter half of the nineteenth century. Here is an example from the New York Sunday Mercury of 31 May 1885 that is the earliest citation of this sense in the Oxford English Dictionary:

Actors and authors tempt their “angels” with new plays which are sure to make all concerned Goulds and Vanderbilts.

It would take capitalism to equate robber barons with immortal, heavenly beings.

Discuss this post


Sources:

Ælfric. “De natiuitate Christi” (Regarding the Nativity of Christ). Ælfric’s Lives of Saints, vol. 1 of 2 (originally published in 4 volumes) (1881). Early English Text Society O.S. 76. London: Oxford UP, 1966, 12. London, British Library, Cotton MS Julius E.vii.

Dictionary of Old English: A to I. University of Toronto, 2018, s.v. engel, n.

Helme, Elizabeth. Louisa; or, the Cottage on the Moor, vol. 1 of 2. London: G. Kearsley, 1787, 81–82. Eighteenth Century Collections Online (ECCO).

Le Fevre, Raoul. The History of Jason (1477). William Caxton, trans. John Munro, ed. Early English Text Society, E.S. 111. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trübner, 1913, 192–93. HathiTrust Digital Archive.

Oxford English Dictionary, third edition, September 2019, s.v. angel, n.

Image credit: York Project (2002). Wikimedia Commons. Public domain image as a mechanical reproduction of a public domain work.

hell

Image of people being tortured by demons and being fed into the gigantic mouth of Satan in the center of the frame. At center left is Christ breaking down the gate to hell and admitting light.

c.1450–1516 oil-on-wood painting of the harrowing of hell by an artist in the school of Hieronymus Bosch. Image of people being tortured by demons and being fed into the gigantic mouth of Satan in the center of the frame. At center left is Christ breaking down the gate to hell and admitting light.

11 November 2022

As a general rule, words that are central to a particular culture date to an early period. Therefore, it is no surprise that hell traces back to Old English, pretty much unchanged in form and meaning. And given that much of the extant Old English corpus is religious in nature and was copied and preserved by Christian monks and nuns, it is no surprise that the word appears some nine hundred times in that corpus. While most of those appearances are in the context of a Christian hell or the Sheol of the Hebrew Bible, some are in reference to pagan abodes of the dead. And indeed hell comes from a common Germanic root relating to the underworld. For example, the Old Icelandic Hel is the name of the goddess who rules over the dead as well as her abode

We see hell in Ælfric of Eynsham’s tenth century translation of Genesis 37:35. The verse is about Jacob learning that his favorite son Joseph has been killed:

Soðlice hys bearn hi gesamnodon to þam þæt hi heora fæder gefrefrodon: he nolde nane frefrunge underfon, ac cwæð wepende: ic fare to minum suna to helle

(Now, his children gathered there to console their father; he would not accept the consolation and said weeping: “I go with my son into hell.”)

Of course, Joseph had not been killed, but rather had been sold into slavery by his jealous brothers.

Hell starts breaking loose by the late sixteenth century. The following is a passage from the anonymous play Misogonus, dating to around 1570:

Stay a while Eupelas I knowe our laboure we shall lose but yet He tell the vnthrift of his detestable dealinge Calsta this honest company or is this an honest sporte to be revelinge and bousinge after such a lewde fashion I thinke hell breake louse when thou gatst ye this porte foure such thou coudst scase fynde in a whole nashion

And by 1600 Shakespeare is telling people to go to hell. From the Merchant of Venice:

One half of me is yours, the other halfe yours,
Mine owne, I would say; but if mine, then yours,
And so all yours; o, these naughty times
Puts barres betweene the owners and their rights;
And so, though yours, not yours, (proue it so)
Let fortune goe to hell for it, not I.

But go to the devil is much older. Geoffrey Chaucer uses that phrase some two hundred years earlier. From The Wife of Bath’s Prologue, in a passage about what makes a woman attractive to a man:

Thou seyst som folk desiren us for richesse,
Somme for oure shap, and somme for oure fairnesse,
And som for she kan outher synge or daunce,
And som for gentillesse and daliaunce;
Som for hir handes and hir armes smale;
Thus goth al to the devel, by thy tale.

(You say some folk desire us for riches,
Some for our shape, and some for our beauty,
And some because she can either sing or dance,
And some for nobility and flirtatiousness;
Some for their hands and their slender arms;
Thus goes all to the devil, by your telling.)

And a bit later, the Wife complains that age has robbed her of her beauty and vigor:

But age, allas, that al wole envenyme,
Hath me biraft my beautee and my pith.
Lat go. Farewel! The devel go therwith!

(But age, alas, that will poison all,
Has robbed me of beauty and vigor.
Let it go. Farewell! Go to the devil with it!

The use of hell as an intensifier and interjection, that is as profanity, appears at about the same time as Shakespeare’s go to hell. From a 1605 satirical play Eastward Hoe by George Chapman, Ben Jonson, and John Marston, a scene where a shipwrecked man washes ashore at a place called Cuckold’s Haven:

Secu[ritie]. Heauen, I beseech thee, how haue I offended thee! where am I cast a shore nowe, that I may goe a righter way home by land? Let me see. O I am scarce able to looke about me! where is there any Sea-marke that I am acquainted withall?

Slit[gut]. Looke vp Father, are you acquainted with this Marke?

Secu. What! landed at Cuckolds hauen? Hell and damnation. I will runne backe and drowne my selfe.

Bloody hell isn’t recorded until the nineteenth century, although oral use is undoubtedly older. The following account of a trial for mutiny onboard a ship was printed in the New Hampshire Patriot and State Gazette on 7 January 1857. The incident had occurred on 19 May 1856:

On the 19th of May, about 7 o’clock A. M., Wales being at the wheel, Capt. Lunt told him to keep the ship before the wind. Wales replied, “Why the bloody hell don’t you give me a course?”—Upon this, Capt. Lunt took him by the collar, when Wales seized the captain by the throat, tore his shirt from him, and was in the act of stabbing him with a sheath knife, when his arm was arrested by the mate.

There is a published use of hell as intensifier between these two dates. From the Daily Cleveland Herald of 1 September 1856 in an account of the last words of Philander Brace from the gallows as he awaited his hanging for murder:

Come, dry up! What the bloody hell is the use of keeping me here just waiting on you? I want to go through with it.

The fact that these early uses of bloody hell, a characteristically British phrase, appear in American newspapers may be due to the fact that the phrase wasn’t considered so offensive on the left side of the pond and was therefore considered fit to print.

And indeed, both bloody hell and hell are recorded in the 1888 West Somerset Word-Book:

Lor! lawk! lawk-a-massy! massy soce! massy ’pon us! strike me! s’elp me! are, of course, mere conjunctives, and with some individuals “Hell! bloody hell!” serve to eke out most sentences.

Discuss this post


Sources:

“California News.” Daily Cleveland Herald (Ohio), 1 September 1856, 2. Gale Primary Sources: Nineteenth Century US Newspapers.

Chapman, George, Ben Jonson, and John Marston. Eastward Hoe. London: William Aspley, 1605, 4.1, sig. F2v. Early English Books Online (EEBO).

Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Wife of Bath’s Prologue and Tale. The Canterbury Tales. lines 257–62. Harvard’s Geoffrey Chaucer Website.

Crawford, S.J. The Old English Version of the Heptateuch (1922). Early English Text Society O.S. 160. London: Oxford UP, 2004, Genesis 37:35, 174.

Dictionary of Old English: A to I. University of Toronto, 2018, s.v. hell, helle, n.

Elworthy, Thomas. The West Somerset Word-Book. English Dialect Society. London: Trübner, 1888, s.v. oaths, imprecations, and exclamations, 530. HathiTrust Digital Archive.

Misogonus (c.1570). 2.5. In Richard Warwick Bond. Early Plays from the Italian. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1911, 215. HathiTrust Digital Archive.

Oxford English Dictionary, third edition, June 2008, s.v. hell, n. and int., Hel, n.; June 2017, s.v. devil, n.

Shakespeare, William. The Most Excellent Historie of the Merchant of Venice. London, James Roberts for Thomas Heyes, 1600, sig. E3v. Folger Shakespeare Library.

“U.S. District Court.” New Hampshire Patriot and State Gazette, 7 January 1857, 2. Readex: America’s Historical Newspapers.

Zoëga. Geir T. A Concise Dictionary of Old Icelandic. Toronto: U of Toronto Press, 2004, s.v. hel, n.

Image credit: Unknown artist, c.1450–1516. Wikimedia Commons. Public domain image as a mechanical reproduction of a public domain work.

mastodon

Painting of a mastodon (Mammut americanum). A hairy, elephant-like creature with long tusks.

Painting of a mastodon (Mammut americanum). A hairy, elephant-like creature with long tusks.

9 November 2022

The mastodon is an extinct animal belonging to the genus Mammut and the order Proboscidea, which includes the mammoth and the present-day elephant. Mastodons ranged throughout North and Central America. They went extinct some 12,000 years ago, at the end of the Pleistocene era.

Mastodon is also the name of a social media platform similar in some respects to Twitter.

The name mastodonte was coined by French naturalist Georges Cuvier in 1806 from the Greek μαστός (mastos, breast) and ὀδούς (odous, tooth) because projections on the crowns of mastodon molars resemble nipples. The form mastodon appears in English by 1811. In those early years, the distinction between and classification of mammoths and mastodons were not firmly set, and it can be difficult to determine in writing from that era which of the present-day classifications those two words refer to.

The English word is borrowed from Cuvier’s French. Thomas Jefferson used mastodont in a 10 September 1809 letter to William Clark, of Lewis and Clark expedition fame:

the bones of this animal are now in such a state of evanescence as to render it important to save what we can of them. of those you had formerly sent me I reserved a very few for myself, got Doctr Wistar to select from the rest every piece [sic] which could be interesting to the Philosophical society, & sent the residue to the National institute of France. these have enabled them to decide that the animal was neither a Mammoth nor an elephant, but of a distinct kind, to which they have given the name of Mastodont, from the protuberances of it’s [sic] teeth. these from their form & the immense mass of their jaws, satisfy me this animal must have been arboriverous. nature seems not to have provided other food sufficient for him; & the limb of a tree would be no more to him than a bough of Cotton tree to a horse.

In 1811, paleontologist and surgeon James Parkinson, who was also the first to describe what we today call Parkinson’s disease, was among the first to use the form mastodon:

Walch, Wallerius and Gmelin, have supposed the fossil jaw found in the neighborhood of Bologna, De Monum. Diluv. In agro bonon. detecto, to have belonged to the walrus; but Cuvier has plainly shown, that it is the remains of a small species of the mammoth (Mastodon), as will be more particularly noticed in a succeeding letter.

I am unable to speak decidedly of a fossil tooth, said to be found in a bed of alluvial matters, in Norfolk. Its substance is very considerably changed: it is about fifteen inches in length, and appears to be nearly perfect at its extremities; although one side of it, and considerable portion of its internal substance is removed. The fineness of its grain and its edge not manifesting the peculiar lozenge-formed decussations observed in the ivory of the elephant and of the mammoth (Mastodon), with the size and form of the tooth, lead to the suspicion of its having belonged to an animal of this genus.

Cartoon drawing of a mastodon used as the mascot for the social media service

Cartoon drawing of a mastodon used as the mascot for the social media service

The social media service named Mastodon was launched on 5 October 2016 by its creator Eugen Rochko. He announced it on the site Hacker News:

Plans for the project: I'm a realist so I don't think that it will be able to compete with Twitter. However I would like this project to become the go-to option for people who are already inclined to prefer decentralized/self-hosted solutions, and simply be better than the other software in that space.

No, I don't plan to monetize. Mastodon is open-source, licensed under AGLPv3. However I do have a Patreon through which interested people could support me while I work on it.

The social media service gained widespread public attention in November 2022 after Elon Musk purchased Twitter and users of that service sought an alternative. Rochko’s choice of Mastodon as the name was apparently random. He commented on the name in Time in November 2022:

That got me thinking that, you know, being able to express myself online to my friends through short messages was actually very important to me, important also to the world, and that maybe it should not be in the hands of a single corporation that can just do whatever it wants with it. I started working on my own thing. I called it Mastodon because I’m not good at naming things. I just chose whatever came to my mind at the time. There was obviously no ambition of going big with it at the time.

Discuss this post


Sources:

Conniff, Richard. “Mammoths and Mastodons: All American Monsters.” Smithsonian, April 2010.

Jefferson, Thomas. Letter to William Clark, 10 September 1809. The Papers of Thomas Jefferson Digital Edition, University of Virginia.

Oxford English Dictionary, third edition, March 2001, s.v. mastodon, n., mastodont, n. and adj.

Parkinson, James. “Letter 22. Fossil Remains of Mammalia.” Organic Remains of a Former World, vol. 3 of 3. London: Sherwood, Neely, and Jones, 1811, 310. Gale Primary Sources: Nineteenth Century Collections Online.

Perrigo, Billy. “Thousands Have Joined Mastodon Since Twitter Changed Hands.” Time, 6 November 2022 (updated 7 November 2022).

Rochko, Eugen (pseudonym Gagron). “Show HN: A New Decentralized Microblogging Platform.” Hacker News, 5 October 2016.

Image credits: Charles R. Knight, 1897. Wikimedia Commons. Public domain image; Rochko, Eugen, 2018, licensed under a GNU Affero General Public License.

calculus

A graph depicting a tangent line and its derivative

A graph depicting a tangent line and its derivative

9 November 2022

[14 November 2022: added the final sentence for clarification]

For many, if not most, calculus is associated with suffering, whether it be suffering through a math class or passing a kidney stone. The word calculus comes from Latin, where it means stone, either a pebble or a hard accretion that forms in the body. Calculus is a diminutive of calx, literally meaning “little stone.” That explains why calculus is a medical term for a kidney stone, but where does the mathematical sense come from?

You’ve probably guessed the correct answer. It comes from calculations using stone counters or abaci.

English use of calculus to mean a small, hard object, be it formed geologically or biologically, dates to Middle English. John Trevisa uses it in his translation of Bartholomæus Anglicus’s De proprietatibus rerum (On the Properties of Things), which was completed sometime before 1398:

Calculus is a litel stoon ymedled with erthe and is round and most hard and pure and most smoþe and playn in euerich syde, and haþ þat name calculus for it is ytrodden with feet wiþoute gref of his smeþenesse and playnnes. And contrarie herto is a litel stoon þat hatte scrupulous “cheselle” and is most rough and scharpe and ful light. If it falleþ betwene a mannes foot and þe schoo it grieueth ful sore. And no such stones þat [ben] scharpe and harde ben cleped scrupea, as Isider seiþ libro xvi. Capitulo iii. And ofte in the body of a beste þis stoon bredeþ of hoote humours and glemy, now in þe bleddre and now in þe reynes, as Costantyn seiþ. Loke byfore libro vii. De passionibus renum.

(Calculus is a little stone mixed with earth and is round and very hard and pure and very smooth and plain on all sides, and has the name calculus for it is trod upon by feet without injury because of its smoothness and plainness. And in contrast to it is a little stone that is called scrupulous “cheselle” and is very rough and sharp and very light. If it falls between a man’s foot and the shoe it hurts very sorely. And no such stones that are sharp and hard are called scrupea, according to Isidore, book 16, chapter 3. And often in the body of a beast this stone grows from hot and viscous humors, sometimes in the bladder and sometimes in the kidneys, according to Constantine [the African]. Look in book 7 of About Diseases of the Kidneys.)

Both scrupulous (Latin) and cheselle or chesil (English) mean small, sharp pebbles or gravel, such as those found on some beaches. The English word comes from the Latin cisellum, a diminutive of caesum (cutting), which is also the root of chisel and scissors.

The mathematical sense of calculus starts to develop in the mid seventeenth century. It is first used to refer to stones or counters used for counting. We see this use in Charles Hoole’s 1649 Latin textbook, although he uses it as a Latin, not an English, word:

a counter, Calculus, li. m.
ship-counters, or counters to cast account with, Abaculi.

But a dozen years later it is recorded as an English word in Thomas Blount’s 1661 Glossographia, a dictionary of “hard words”:

Calcule (calculus) and account or reckoning; a Table-man, Chess-man, or Counter to cast accounts withal.

And by the end of the seventeenth century, calculus is being used to mean a method of calculation. From John Arbuthnot’s 1692 Of the Laws of Chance:

The Calculus of the preceeding Problems is left out by Mons. Hugens, on purpose that the ingenious Reader may have the satisfaction of applying the former Method himself; it is in most of them more laborious than difficult.

And the specific terms differential calculus and integral calculus are in place by first half of the eighteenth century. These are not direct developments within English, but rather calques of French and German to describe the work of Leibniz.

Discuss this post


Sources:

Arbuthnot, John. Of the Laws of Chance. London: Benjamin Motte, 1692, 48. Early English Books Online (EEBO).

Blount, Thomas. Glossographia, or, a Dictionary Interpreting All Such Hard Words of Whatsoever Language Now Used in Our Refined English Tongue. London: Thomas Newcombe for George Sawbridge, 1661, s.v. calcule. Early English Books Online (EEBO).

Hoole, Charles. An Easie Entrance to the Latine Tongue. London: William Dugard for Joshua Kirton, 1649, 309. Early English Books Online (EEBO).

Lewis, Charlton T. and Charles Short. A Latin Dictionary. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1879, s.v. calculus, n. Brepols: Database of Latin Dictionaries.

Middle English Dictionary, 2019, s.v. calculus, n.

Oxford English Dictionary, second edition, 1989, s.v. calculus, n., integral, adj. and n.; third edition, March 2016, s.v. differential, adj. and n.

Trevisa, John. On the Properties of Things: John Trevisa’s Translation of Bartholomæus Anglicus De Proprietatibus Rerum, vol. 2 of 3. Oxford: Clarendon Press: 1975, 16.20, 837–38.

Image credit: Cristian Quinzacara, 2021. Wikimedia Commons. Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

earl

Statue of a bearded man in helmet and mail armor, holding a round shield at his side and a sword aloft.

Statue of Byrhtnoth, the English earl who died leading the English forces against Danish raiders at Maldon in 991 CE. The statue was created by sculptor John Doubleday and stands at the battle site. Statue of a bearded man in helmet and mail armor, holding a round shield at his side and a sword aloft.

7 November 2022

Earl is a title of English nobility, corresponding in rank to the Continental count. It comes to us from the Old English eorl, although that term did not have quite the same meaning as it would in later periods. It’s cognate with a number of words in other Germanic languages, such as the Old Saxon erl (man), the Old Icelandic and Danish jarl, the Norn iarl, and the Old Swedish iärl. Its further etymology is uncertain, but it could come from the same root as the Old Icelandic jara (battle) or ern (vigorous, which would give us earnest).

Early medieval England did not have the complex hierarchy of rank that would be present in later periods, and originally eorl wasn’t a specific rank or title, but was rather a generic designation for a nobleman. As such, it contrasted with ceorl (churl), which referred to a free commoner, a peasant. Here is an example of this general sense from the poem The Battle of Maldon. The battle was fought in 991 CE, and the poem was probably written within a few years of the battle:

Wod þa wiges heard,    wæpen up ahof,
bord to gebeorge,    and wið þæs beornes stop.
Eode swa anræd    eorl to þam ceorle,
ægþer hyra oðrum    yfeles hogode.

(The battle-hardened one advanced, his weapon upraised, his shield as protection, and stepped toward that man. The earl approached the churl just as resolutely, each of them intended harm to the other.)

While The Battle of Maldon uses the word in its usual meaning, there was also a poetic use of eorl meaning a warrior, which makes sense given that noblemen were essentially professional warriors. We can see this poetic use in Beowulf, in the scene where Beowulf has come into Heorot and is about to greet Hrothgar:

Hwearf þa hrædlice    þær Hroðgar sæt
eald ond anhar    mid his eorla gedriht;
eode ellen-rof,    þæt he for eaxlum gestod
Deniga frean;    cuþe he duguðe þeaw.

(He then quickly turned to where Hrothgar sat, old and gray, with his retinue of earls; he went boldly until he stood before (lit. “before the shoulders”) of the king of the Danes; he knew the custom of that people.)

While in its early use eorl simply meant a nobleman of any rank, in later use it took on the additional sense of a specific title. This sense was borrowed from Old Norse, where jarl was a specific noble title, a result of the Danelaw and Danish occupation of much of England. An example of its use as a title can be found in a charter from c.1058 in which King Edward the Confessor affirms the traditional right and title to lands held by priests in Herefordshire. The charter opens with a formulaic greeting that refers to the nobles of that region:

Edward king gret Alred Eurl and Harald Eurl and all his underlynges in Herefordshire ffrendelich.

(King Edward greets in friendship Earl Alred and Earl Harald and all his subjects in Hereforshire.)

It would be the Normans who would create the complex hierarchy of nobility in which an earl ranks above a viscount and below a marquess and equivalent to a Continental count. The female equivalent of an earl is a countess.

Discuss this post


Sources:

Dictionary of Old English: A to I, 2018, s.v. eorl, n.

Dobbie, Elliott Van Kirk. “The Battle of Maldon.” The Anglo-Saxon Minor Poems. The Anglo-Saxon Poetic Record 6. New York: Columbia UP, 1942, lines 130–33.

Fulk, R.D. The Beowulf Manuscript. Dumbarton Oaks Medieval Library 3. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 2010, lines 356–59. London, British Library, Cotton MS Vitellius A.xv.

“Harm 49.” Anglo-Saxon Writs. F.E. Harmer, ed. Manchester: Manchester UP: 1952, Oxford, Bodleian Library, MS Rawlinson B.329, fol. 104.

Middle English Dictionary, 2019, s.v. erl, n.

Oxford English Dictionary, third edition, March 2015, s.v. earl, n.

Photo credit: Oxyman, 2008. Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.